The oyster sloop Modesty was built in 1923 by The Wood and Chute Shipyard of Greenport, Long Island. Modeled after the catboat Honest, which was built in 1892 by Jelle Dykstra on the west bank of Greens Creek, West Sayville. Modesty was built as a gaff-rigged sloop, but retained the extreme beam of a catboat.
For auxiliary power, a two-cylinder Gafka gasoline engine was installed.
Modesty was described by oystermen as a true "southsider". She is believed to be the last sailing scallop dredger built on Long Island. A beautiful vessel, a fine sailer and typical of the old oyster sloops. Her lines show graceful proportions in hull and rig. She has a wide beam and sits low in the water. Her shallow draft permitted her to operated commercially in the oyster and scallop flats of Long Island's bays and the rivers estuaries of Connecticut.